| Games | Athlete/Team | Placement | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2004 Summer Olympics | Mariel Zagunis | 1 | Gold |
| Sada Jacobson | 3 | Bronze | |
| Emily Jacobson | 12 | ||
| 2008 Summer Olympics | Mariel Zagunis | 1 | Gold |
| Sada Jacobson | 2 | Silver | |
| Becca Ward | 3 | Bronze | |
| 2012 Summer Olympics | Mariel Zagunis | 4 | |
| Dagmara Wozniak | =5 | ||
| 2016 Summer Olympics | Mariel Zagunis | 9 | |
| Ibtihaj Muhammad | 12 | ||
| Dagmara Wozniak | 24 | ||
| 2020 Summer Olympics | Mariel Zagunis | 5 | |
| Eliza Stone | 19 | ||
| Dagmara Wozniak | 25 | ||
| 2024 Summer Olympics | Elizabeth Tartakovsky | 18 | |
| Tatiana Nazlymov | 21 | ||
| Magda Skarbonkiewicz | 22 |