| Games | Athlete/Team | Placement | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1904 Summer Olympics | Christian Brothers' College | 2 | Silver |
| St. Rose | 3 | Bronze | |
| 1924 Summer Olympics | United States | =9 | |
| 1928 Summer Olympics | United States | 9 | |
| 1936 Summer Olympics | United States | =9 | |
| 1948 Summer Olympics | United States | =9 | |
| 1952 Summer Olympics | United States | =17 | |
| 1956 Summer Olympics | United States | =5 | |
| 1972 Summer Olympics | United States | =13 | |
| 1984 Summer Olympics | United States | =9 | |
| 1988 Summer Olympics | United States | =13 | |
| Jeff Duback | DNS | ||
| Eric Eichmann | DNS | ||
| Jim Gabarra | DNS | ||
| Steve Trittschuh | DNS | ||
| 1992 Summer Olympics | United States | 9 | |
| Ian Feuer | DNS | ||
| Chris Henderson | DNS | ||
| Zak Ibsen | DNS | ||
| 1996 Summer Olympics | United States | 10 | |
| 2000 Summer Olympics | United States | 4 | |
| DaMarcus Beasley | DNS | ||
| Chris Brown | DNS | ||
| Tim Howard | DNS | ||
| Matt Napoleon | DNS | ||
| Brian Winters | DNS | ||
| 2008 Summer Olympics | United States | 9 | |
| 2024 Summer Olympics | United States | 8 |